“Leave
the Books”
Each time a man stands up for an ideal, or acts to improve the lot of
others, or strikes out against injustice, he sends forth a tiny ripple of hope,
and crossing each other from a million different centers of energy and daring,
those ripples build a current which can sweep down the mightiest walls of
oppression and injustice.
-
Senator Robert F. Kennedy, Day of Affirmation Address at
the
University of Capetown, South Africa, 1966
The
best thing about the start of the new school year was the warm reunion with all
my students. The worst thing was saying goodbye to 14-year-old Philip as
I sent him off to live with his sister Connie in Massachusetts. I knew
he’d be happy there, and safer than if he stayed in Mound Bayou, but his
departure left an ache. Only two of my four children remained, and our
once full home felt empty.
As a result, it was actually a blessing that
I’d suddenly become so busy. I continued to thrive at the high school and
I loved being a student again. My favorite class at Delta State College
was Adolescent Psychology. The professor was excellent and the subject
fascinated me. Every day in class we discussed what goes on in the mind
of a teenager. The other students could draw only on their personal
experiences of adolescence, but I had the added perspective of parenting my own
teenage children and teaching at the local high school.
The first time this became apparent was in a
conversation about how much freedom parents should give their teenagers in
selecting a college. Some
students believed that 18 was old enough to make important life
decisions. Others said the
parents were entitled to choose because they were footing the bill. One young man repeated what his father
had said. “If your feet are
under my table, I have the right and duty to make the decisions.”
Eventually, several students turned to me and asked
what I thought. I said, “If your feet are under my table, it’s my duty to
see you are well fed.” They all laughed and I could see some of them
thinking about whether they would dare share this sentiment with their
parents.
Often, my comments included anecdotes about my
experiences not just with my own children, but also with my students in Mound
Bayou. I made no secret of the fact that I lived and worked in an
all-black town. One morning, a young lady walked up to me after class and
asked to speak to me for a few minutes. She warned me there were members
of the Ku Klux Klan and White Citizens Council in the class. She said my
life was in danger because of my views and begged me to be more careful about
what I said.
After we talked for several minutes, I invited her
to come home with me for lunch to continue our conversation. She thanked
me for the offer and said she’d love to talk some more, but she was afraid to
go to Mound Bayou. I promised her she could follow me in her car right to
my front door and then walk only a few steps into the house. Trusting
that my presence would protect her, she accepted my invitation. Know-
ing the
white community viewed us as low-class trash for our involvement in Mound
Bayou, I set an elaborate table using bone china, crystal and sterling silver,
with the results as elegant as anything you’d find in the richest mansion in
the state. Although I personally didn’t value such displays any more, I
knew she’d been brought up to do so. My serving her in this manner made
it easier for her to respect me and listen to what I had to say.
During the meal, she told me more about
herself, beginning with the fact that she was Senator Eastland’s niece.
No wonder she was afraid to come to Mound Bayou! She’d grown up in a
family that was terrified of Blacks, believing they should be kept completely
separate from white society. Her uncle was the state’s foremost spokesman
for segregation, quoted on National Public Radio for his comments when
addressing a meeting of the White Citizens Council: “When in the course
of human events it becomes necessary to abolish the Negro race, proper methods
should be used. Among these are guns, bows and arrows, slingshots and
knives.” [See quotation on
Google. It gets worse. bbm]
My young guest said her uncle would have a fit if he knew where she was.
I encouraged her to tell him, saying perhaps she could influence him to
change. She said it was hopeless. She knew the attitudes he
represented were wrong, but she lacked the courage to defy everything she’d
been taught. By the end of our meal, however, she said, “After meeting
you and hearing what you have to say, maybe one day I’ll light my own little
candle.” As I walked her to her car, I felt elated by the potential for
change I saw in her. My decision to earn a teaching certificate might
have far-reaching effects, helping me to influence not only my black high
school students, but my white college classmates as well.
Meanwhile, Jo was becoming dissatisfied with the Catholic school.
We’d initially placed the children there because of its academic reputation
relative to the public school. The teachers were better trained and the
classes smaller, so we were willing to put our Jewish children in a Catholic
setting. We also viewed this as an opportunity to expose them to a
religion other than their own. Often, over dinner, we’d discuss the
differences between Judaism and Catholicism, pleased when we could find
similarities.
As the children started
their second year at the mission school, however, Jo began to object to the
strict religious training. In
5th grade, she’d been interested to learn about the Christian Bible, but her
6th grade teacher expanded upon the religion curriculum and used it for her
history class as well. When
called on to give rote answers based on a literal interpretation of the Bible,
Jo refused. She also
objected to being ordered to say prayers and cross herself before each
class. Her teacher’s
response was to say, “None of the other students object and they’re not all
Catholic. Why should you be
any different? Judaism’s
just a different Christian denomination.”
It was only a week into the school year when Sister Rosarita asked
Leon and me to come discuss the situation. She recognized that Jo was in
a difficult situation and suggested that everybody might be happier if we
transferred our daughter to the public school. When we told Jo what
Sister had said, she was cheered by the prospect, remembering how much
Philip had preferred 9th grade at the public school to 8th grade at the
Catholic school. She asked if she could move up to 7th grade in the
process of transferring, and we agreed.
The next day, 11-year-old Jo started junior high. She
immediately ran into trouble in her math class. She watched as her
teacher showed the class how to do long division, something Jo had mastered 2
years earlier in Newton. As he worked a simple problem on the blackboard,
Jo saw that he was describing it incorrectly. He said, “Seven goes into
28 four times. Write the number 4 over the twenty-eight. Next,
since you can’t divide zero by 7, ignore it. Finally, 7 goes into 7
once. The answer is forty-one.”
__41_
7)2807
-28__
7
__-7
0
Jo raised
her hand and said, “You can’t ignore the zero,” and then she explained how the
problem should have been done, concluding with,
“The correct answer is four hundred one.”
Instead of recognizing his
mistake and correcting it, the teacher was annoyed and told Jo to be
quiet. Had Jo been older,
she might have thought to approach the teacher later in private to discuss the
issue, or she might have sought adult advice regarding what to do. But, in the heartless manner typical
of pre-teens, Jo kept pushing, asking the teacher to check his answer using
multiplication. When he
tried to do so, he saw that his answer was wrong and corrected his work.
While Jo viewed the interaction as an invigorating
debate she was proud of winning, the teacher was upset and came to our
home that evening to discuss the situation with Leon and me. He said he knew he was inadequate as a
math teacher. He’d majored
in industrial arts and wanted to teach shop, but the school needed a math
teacher. As ill prepared as
he was, he knew more math than any of his colleagues, and if he didn’t teach
it, there would be no class. He
ended by saying how frustrated he was because he knew that if Jo hadn’t pointed
out his error, he would have taught all his students the wrong thing, and they
would later be labeled stupid for not knowing something as basic as long
division.
With Leon teaching in the evenings and
my attendance at graduate school, the dinner hour became the only occasion we
were all together as a family. After we each shared the events of the day
and our plans for the next, we cleaned up the dishes and rushed out for
the next round of activity, leaving the children on their own. With no
television or radio to keep them entertained, Charles and Jo spent the evenings
studying, reading, and playing music. I’d get home from Delta State just
in time to say goodnight and then we’d all collapse.
The weekends, however, were ours to share as a family. Leon
and I taught the children how to play bridge and we spent many a pleasant
Saturday evening around the card table, classical music playing softly in the
background. Whenever I was dummy, I’d retire to the couch where I picked
up my knitting, my hands flying as I worked on the children’s Christmas
presents. With all the poverty around us, it somehow seemed right to
focus on making our gifts this year, rather than buying them.
With the arrival of the holidays, my parents came to visit,
expecting to find us living in poverty, surrounded by people with whom we had
nothing in common. They were pleasantly surprised when they walked into
our trailers and saw that although we had downsized from our 10-room home in
Newton, we were comfortable. I could see them smiling as they recognized
the furniture they’d given us over the years. They were doubly pleased to
see pictures my father had painted hanging on the walls.
We introduced them to our friends and they were again surprised
that we’d been able to connect with interesting, intelligent people in the
midst of the cotton fields. Our closest friends, Pauline and Preston
Holmes, invited the four of us to their home one evening for dessert.
Preston got into a lively discussion with my father, who viewed himself as
politically astute and believed he had the answer to every problem.
Dad argued for change from within the system. He was
adamantly against what he viewed as unnecessary confrontation and said that if
Blacks would just get involved in politics and begin voting, everything would
be better. Preston smiled and began listing examples of how Blacks in the
Deep South were systematically prevented from voting. He explained that
what my father was proposing had already been tried and had failed.
Not
to be deterred, Dad absorbed this new information and said, as if he were the
first to think of it, “Then white people need to get out there and help.”
Preston answered, “They do. They’re called freedom riders.”
The look on Dad’s face said it all. Preston, in his gentle,
non-argumentative style, had finally made my father understand why we felt a
need to be there. My parents couldn’t agree with what we were doing, but
at least they stopped complaining.
Not long after that, Helen and Henry Lerner came to visit. As far-left Democrats, they’d supported our decision to leave Newton.
Despite this, they were unprepared for what they found when they arrived in
Mound Bayou. They didn’t seem to notice that we were comfortable and
healthy, had a pleasant home, and were surrounded by good friends. In a
letter he sent to the extended family on his return to Boston, Henry described
our living conditions as “horrifying” and praised us for our bravery.
While we appreciated the admiration, we found it disturbing that he saw our
lives as miserable.
Henry’s observations were in sharp contrast to the reactions of
David and Susan, the two Kramer children who flew down to see us.
Twenty-year-old David walked into the trailers, looked around, and
then said, his voice heavy with emotion, “You’ve recreated your Newton
home in the middle of the cotton fields.” Susan went out with our
children and made friends. Neither of them saw our surroundings as horrifying.
The holidays passed and the spring semester got underway.
All over the country, people who’d been deeply disturbed by the assassination
of Martin Luther King, Jr. the previous spring talked about celebrating his
birthday on January fifteenth.
It would be 17 years before the federal government declared the
day a national holiday, but my students wanted to do something immediately
and proposed to boycott their classes in protest. I urged them to stay in
school, saying this was what Dr. King would have wanted. So instead, they
asked the administration to allow them to conduct a memorial assembly, much as
we’d done the spring before.
The students used my classroom as their base of operations,
planning the program, selecting literature and political quotes to read aloud,
and rehearsing their speeches. The event was moving and I felt very close
to my young charges. Apparently, they felt close to me as well, for a few
days later I found an anonymous note on my desk saying I’d been made an
honorary Black Panther. Many people might have found this unnerving,
viewing the Black Panthers as an organization devoted to violence and the
overthrow of our government. But I knew that although they espoused
violence when used in self-defense, they were a strong political force that was
in many ways commendable.
Founded in Oakland, California in 1966 by Huey Newton and Bobby
Seale, their original purpose was to fight police brutality in the black
ghetto. They established patrols to monitor police activity and protect
ghetto residents from abusive officers. As the organization spread across
the country, eventually sponsoring chapters in every major city, they began to
help ghetto residents in other ways as well. They arranged for free
breakfasts for school children and free medical clinics for those who were sick
or injured. They helped the homeless find housing and gave away clothing
and food. We had discussed this numerous times in my classroom and I
routinely posted newspaper articles about their activities on my bulletin board.
When I read the note left on my desk, I thought about all the positive things
the Panthers were doing, and was proud to be a member.
A few weeks after this, Leon’s boss, Jack Geiger, showed up
unexpectedly and told Leon he wanted to come by the house that evening to
talk. Work was not going as smoothly as everyone had hoped and Leon was
worried that Jack might be unhappy with him. He was right to worry, for
Jack suggested Leon begin looking for work elsewhere.
After Jack left, Leon came into our bedroom, crestfallen. Jack
hadn’t said one word of appreciation for all Leon had accomplished in the
year-and-a-half we’d lived in Mound Bayou, nor did he give any reasons for his
decision to ask Leon to leave. I tried to cheer him up by reminding him
the original plan was for him to spend 2 years with the clinic and then turn
it over to local physicians. I told him we should go to sleep and start
making plans for the future in the morning. When the new day arrived,
Leon was determined to make the most of his remaining
time. He still had a lot he wanted to accomplish at the clinic and was
confident that with the experience he’d gained in Mississippi, he’d have no
difficulty landing a similar job elsewhere.
As I thought about Leon’s desire to make his last few months at
the clinic worthwhile, I knew I had to do the same at the high school.
The time had come for me to figure out what to do with the $1,000 we’d
been given by the family of one of Leon’s patients to help the
townspeople. I decided to buy classroom sets of 4 paperback
books: Where Do We Go
from Here: Chaos or Community? by
Dr. Martin Luther, King Jr., The
Autobiography of Malcolm X, as told to Alex Haley, Shakespeare’s Othello, and an anthology
called Currents in Poetry.
Leon thought this was a great idea and added that we should give the remainder
of the money to Father Guidry to help students at the Catholic school.
It didn't occurr to me to seek approval from my high school
before buying the books. We’d been discussing both Dr. King and Malcolm X
in my classroom the entire year. Articles about them covered my bulletin
board. However, when the books arrived, it set off a firestorm in the
community. How dare I bring such incendiary material into the
classroom? Before I had a chance to take the books from their boxes, the
superintendent called me to his office and said he preferred I not use them.
Struggling to understand why he didn’t want me to expose my
students to the actual writings of these men about whom they’d heard so much, I
asked, “Don’t you want to become involved in the civil rights movement?”
Without a moment’s hesitation, he answered, “No.” Then he went on to explain
his reluctance, saying that he was afraid if I introduced the books, the white
community in the nearby towns would get upset and the safe environment we’d
enjoyed for so many years would go up in smoke, perhaps literally.
I went home that evening feeling disturbed and confused. Who
was I, an older, well-to-do white woman, to make political decisions with which
the locals disagreed? Leon and I discussed my dilemma over dinner and he
promised to seek advice from his colleagues at the clinic. The next
night, he told me that they had suggested I speak with Aaron Henry, president
of the Mississippi Chapter of the NAACP.
I’d heard many good things about Mr. Henry, known nationally for
bringing an integrated delegation to the 1964 Democratic Convention and
demanding to be seated. He said his group of delegates was more
representative of Mississippi than the all-white one that had been sent by the
state party. Eventually, both delegations were allowed in as a
compromise. Given his extensive experience fighting for civil rights and
the successes he’d achieved, I was excited by the prospect of meeting with him.
That weekend we drove the 40 miles north to Clarksdale to Mr.
Henry's drugstore. The three of us sat down at a table, and I described my
situation, telling him of my frustration and doubts and asking if he thought I
was introducing appropriate material into my classroom. He said he
thought everything I was doing was fine and wanted to know why I was unsure of
myself. When I told him it was hard to feel confident when I found myself
fighting against Blacks, he said, “Welcome to the club.” I listened in
amazement as he told me that for many years, he’d battled other Blacks in his
efforts to bring the civil rights movement to Mississippi.
Mr. Henry was all too familiar with my plight and assured me I was
on the right track, difficult as it was. He pressed me not to give up,
saying my students and the townspeople needed me, whether they knew it or not,
and he suggested I look up a man named Dr. Burton. His last statement
surprised me. Dr. Burton lived in a large red brick house in the center
of Mound Bayou and seemed to have nothing to do with the townspeople. Mr.
Henry explained that the good doctor was an ardent civil rights advocate and
could be helpful. I promised I’d call Dr. Burton when I got home and seek
his support.
As it turned out, Leon and I both had important calls to make.
Shortly after I spoke with Dr. Burton and arranged to visit with him, Leon
called the University of Miami about the possibility of setting up a clinic in
Liberty City, the black ghetto of Miami. We’d heard about riots there the
previous summer and knew the community could benefit from a clinic like the one
Leon had built in Mound Bayou, but it hadn’t occurred to Leon to seek work
there until he was told by Jack Geiger that he’d be out of a job in June.
The University was intrigued with Leon’s call and asked him to come for an
interview, saying he should plan to spend a whole week in discussions.
Miami! Not only did I love the beauty of the place, but also
my parents had settled there when we left Boston for Mississippi. I
thought this might discourage Leon from moving there, for although I was almost 50 years old, I still found it difficult to stand up to my father, and this
always annoyed Leon. We didn’t discuss it, however, so I assumed Leon
had decided not to worry about it. In fact he said that it would be nice for us to reunite with parents.
Other family members would be there as well. Helen and Henry
Lerner had been wintering in Coconut Grove for several years and often told us how much they loved it. Their daughter Toby and her husband lived
in the area, as did Leon’s cousin Frieda, whom I’d met during our army days.
For the first time in two years, I would have family with whom I could share my life.
Leon left the next day. I wished him luck on his interviews
and he wished me luck on my upcoming discussion with Dr. Burton. The
following morning, I was surprised when my neighbor’s younger sister approached
me about the meeting. Jackie lived with her brother, Earl Lucas and his
family, and taught at the high school with me. Despite living next door
to each other and working together, we’d not gotten to know each other beyond
saying hello when passing in the yard or at school. This was about to
change. She’d heard about my intention to talk with Dr. Burton and
offered to join me.
I cautioned Jackie, saying she should reconsider because of possible damage to her reputation. She thanked me for my concern, but said she wished
to support me because she believed in the same things I did, and did not want
me to be in this fight alone. Together, Jackie and I walked to Dr.
Burton’s. He listened attentively while I explained the situation, and when
I told him of my hesitancy to continue in my battle to educate my students
about civil rights when the black leaders in the community didn’t want me to do
so, he repeated what Aaron Henry had said and encouraged me to carry on.
After that, Jackie admitted she’d been afraid in the past to come to my
support, but was glad she’d changed her mind. Dr. Burton praised her for
getting involved and said it was important for her to continue doing so.
Once it was clear he believed I was on the right path, I sought
his advice on how to proceed. I told him there was a PTA meeting
scheduled for the following evening and asked if he thought this would be a
good time to raise the issue of the books. Dr. Burton said he thought it
was the perfect opportunity, after which Jackie said she wanted the privilege
of introducing the subject. Dr. Burton smiled as he witnessed her growing
enthusiasm and warned us there would be a lively discussion, even a
battle. He ended by promising to be there.
As we walked home, Jackie said she’d pick me up and take me to the
PTA meeting. Having made her decision to support my efforts, she wanted
to demonstrate it to the entire community by walking in with me. She
wanted every parent, teacher, and school administrator to know she believed it
was right for me to introduce the books into my classroom, even if she lost her
job as a result. I tried to talk her out of it, pointing out that she could ill-afford to be fired, but she was adamant.
“I’ve been quiet for too long," she said. "It’s time for me to take a
stand.”
We hugged good-bye on the street in front of our homes, and I
walked into the trailers totally drained.
It was difficult to fall asleep that night, despite my exhaustion. I wished Leon were there to talk over all that had happened, to strategize about the
upcoming PTA meeting, to have him reassure me I was doing the right thing by
bringing the controversial books into my classroom. I was also eager to
hear how he was faring in Miami, whether the University was open to the idea of
a clinic in Liberty City, and if they would consider hiring him to manage
it. I kept hoping the phone would ring and I’d hear Leon’s voice saying
all was well on his end and that he knew I’d be fine at the PTA meeting.
When that didn’t happen, I willed myself to relax and fall asleep, knowing I
had a big day of teaching ahead of me, and an even bigger evening.
When Jackie and I walked into the PTA meeting in the school
auditorium, there were over 200 parents waiting for it to begin – a
record turnout. The chairperson banged his gavel, called for order, had
the minutes read, and led the discussion on old business.
Caught up in my
thoughts about what I would say regarding the books, I found it hard to concentrate
on his words and was startled when he suddenly said, “Since there is no new
business, this meeting is closed,” and turned to leave the podium.
Jackie
jumped to her feet and called out, “Excuse me, Mr. Chairman, there is new business. We want to discuss
the books Mrs. Kruger wants to bring into her classroom.” A clamor arose
and it took the chairperson a few moments to settle everyone down. Then
he said, “School business is not on the agenda for the PTA.” This was the
first time I’d ever heard that argument used. School business not on the
agenda? It made no sense at all.
Dr. Burton stood and a hush fell over the crowd. Clearly, he
was a highly regarded member of the community and everyone, board members
included, wanted to hear what he had to say. At first, the chairman
declared him out of order since he was not a bona fide member of the PTA.
In response, Dr. Burton asked how much it cost to join and when he was told one
dollar, reached into his pocket, took out a bill, and placed it on the table.
“Now I’m a member,” he said. “I wonder how many of you have actually read these books that Mrs.
Kruger wishes to introduce into her classroom. Dr. King and Malcolm X
have created modern-day classics that are being read all over our
country. Othello is a traditional classic, written by
the great playwright William Shakespeare, required reading in many high schools
and critical for any student wanting to go to college.”
Having explained why he personally believed the books belonged in
the classroom, he went on to say, “I suggest the PTA wait a week before making
any decisions. Every one of us should use that time to read the books and
understand why Mrs. Kruger believes they are appropriate for her students
before we consider banning them.” There was a hum of approval throughout
the room.
A young man stood on his chair and began to speak.
“Most of
you don’t know me. I’ve come from out of town because my friends and I
heard about your meeting tonight and we were thrilled that the high school in
Mound Bayou was brave enough to consider bringing Martin Luther King and
Malcolm X into the classroom. I came, eager to meet the young, black
militant spearheading the effort. Imagine my surprise to see a tiny,
middle-aged white woman instead. Rather than preventing her from
teaching, you should get down and kiss her feet.”
The room was charged with emotion as everyone considered his
words. Jackie stood to speak again, but when she tried, her voice broke
and she couldn’t continue. The
chairperson adjourned the meeting, promising there would be further discussion
when they next met. I was immediately surrounded by parents eager to
assure me of their support. Jackie and I were hugged over and over as
people thanked us for daring to speak out. One mother placed her arms protectively
around Jackie and said to everyone, “If something is going on at this school
that makes a teacher cry, then we parents have a responsibility to look into
it. And we will.”
A couple of days went by without incident. The four boxes of
books remained unopened on the floor of my classroom, waiting for approval from
the school board. I continued teaching, discussing with my
students the political process underway around them and pointing out the
opportunity they had to observe first-hand how change could be accomplished.
In the meantime, Leon called to say his talks with the University
of Miami had gone well. They didn’t think it was feasible to open a
clinic in Liberty City, as Leon had proposed, but they had funding for a health
center for migrant farm workers and wanted to hire him to run it. They’d
settled on either the town of Homestead, about twenty miles south of Miami, or
the Seminole village of Immokalee, a little further to the west. We could
move as soon as the school year was over. As much as I’d grown to care
about the people of Mound Bayou and felt sad to be leaving, I was delighted
that Leon had found another opportunity and everything seemed to be falling
into place.
How quickly all that sense of well being disappeared! It was
Saturday morning, peaceful and quiet. Jo had gone out to play with her
friends in the neighborhood and I could hear piano music coming from the other
trailer, telling me Charles was busy practicing. By late the following
morning, Leon would be calling to tell me his plane had landed safely in
Memphis and it would be only a few hours before we were together again.
He would tell me all about his trip to Miami and I would tell him all about the
PTA meeting.
The next thing I knew, I heard Jo in the back yard and could tell
something was wrong. She was having difficulty climbing the back steps,
leaning against her friend and using a crutch fashioned from a stick. Her
face was contorted in pain as she tried to hold back her tears. As I
reached to help her and asked what had happened, she sank to the floor and
cried out “My leg, my leg!”
I knelt beside her and wrapped my arms around her. She
buried her face on my shoulder, finally letting the tears flow, shaking with
sobs. Not wanting to wait until she could talk again to find out what was
wrong, I turned to her friend for an explanation. He looked terrified, as
if I might blame him for Jo’s injury. Barely able to speak, he stammered that he and Jo had been playing in a tree house near our backyard when 4 older boys climbed up and attacked her. He kept saying he was sorry he’d
been unable to stop them. He’d tried to run for help, but one of the boys
held him down while the others beat up Jo. When it was all over, she fell
from the tree house and couldn’t get up or stand on her own. I thanked
him for bringing Jo home and then he slipped away before I could ask any more
questions.
After several minutes, Jo calmed down enough to talk.
Between sobs, she told me the boys had tried to get her clothes off and she was
afraid they were going to rape her. She was only 11 years old and
shouldn’t have even known what rape was, yet here she was telling me about her
horrifying experience. She said, “I knew one of them, Mom, and said I’d
tell on him. I didn’t know the others, but I recognized him and said he’d
get in trouble. He got scared and tried to get the others to stop.”
I asked Jo if she thought she could stand and walk well enough to
get to her room. She said she’d try, so I helped her up and we stumbled
together from the porch into the trailer and then to her bedroom. The
whole time she was leaning on me, I kept reminding myself of the many times I’d
worked with injured children in Leon’s pediatric office in Newton and forced
myself to remain calm, putting my emotions on hold so I could help Jo.
Once I had her lying on the bed, I knew I had to determine how
badly she was hurt. I began pulling her jeans down, but every
movement made her cringe. She began to cry again and it took all my
strength to continue. Her left leg was swollen above the knee, turning
black and blue, and I was afraid it was broken. .
I gently rubbed her leg and asked her to tell me again what had
happened. She repeated that she’d been molested, not raped, but wouldn’t
tell me what she meant by that. She then said that the boy she knew was
the 14-year-old living across the street. I was livid, furious that
a neighbor, the older brother of one of Jo’s friends, could do this to
her. I told her to lie still while I ran across the street and that I’d
be back in a few minutes. Before I left, I told Charles what had
happened and he offered to sit with his sister while I was gone.
As soon as I ran out of the trailer, I saw the boy standing alone
in his front yard. I grabbed him by the hand and dragged him into his
house to his grandmother. She was sitting in the parlor with her older
grandson. When I told them what had happened and that I needed to get Jo
to the clinic, the older boy offered to help. As he and I ran out of the
house, I overheard the grandmother say to the younger boy, “How many times have
I told you to leave girls alone?”
When we returned, Jo was lying quietly on her bed, half
asleep. The young man lifted her in his arms and carried her to my car,
gently setting her down in the back seat. She remained limp throughout,
seeming to be in a daze. I was worried that she might have sustained head
injuries as well as a broken leg.
The physician in charge while Leon was in Florida was a surgeon
named Harvey Sanders. I knew him well. Jo, completely out of it by
this time, was taken into an examining room while I told Dr. Sanders everything
I knew. He suggested I wait in the corridor while he examined Jo, knowing
from past experience that parents were not always able to deal with seeing
their children’s injuries.
I couldn’t sit down, and instead paced back and forth, waiting to
hear Dr. Sanders’ assessment. As I turned toward the front door of the
clinic, I saw the 14-year-old from across the street along with three
older boys who I assumed were Jo’s attackers. They wanted to apologize,
to say they hadn’t meant to hurt her, but I couldn’t listen and walked
away. I couldn’t stand there talking calmly with them while my little
girl lay barely conscious in the room behind us.
A few minutes later, Dr. Sanders came out, took my hand in his, and sat me down. He said Jo had major contusions on
her leg, two broken ribs, and a concussion. He said it was a miracle she
had been able to walk home after the attack; he didn’t expect her to be able to
put any weight on her leg for several days. He added that he hadn’t done
a pelvic exam to check for rape, but believed Jo knew what rape involved and
was accurate in her statement that it hadn’t happened.
I was appreciative of everything Dr. Sanders did that day.
In addition to treating Jo, he made sure I was all right, worrying that with
Leon out of town, the turmoil of having my daughter attacked might be
more than I could handle. He sent a nurse home with me to help move Jo
from the car to the bed and a few hours later, he sent another doctor to check
on us. After examining Jo, the doctor stayed for a couple of hours and we
talked. She expressed concern about the lasting psychological effect of
the experience and how it might impact Jo’s relationships with boys. This gave me one more thing to worry about.
After the doctor left, I tried to sleep, but couldn’t. Every
time I closed my eyes, I pictured Jo in the tree house with the boys, and the
image was unbearable. I kept blaming myself for
bringing her to Mississippi in the first place. If the children and I had remained safe in Boston while Leon worked in Mound Bayou, Philip would
still be living with me instead of in Amherst, Charles could have gotten the
psychological help he needed, and Jo would never have been beaten up.
When morning arrived, Jo seemed to be feeling better. Dr.
Sanders dropped by to see how she was and said we could stop worrying about the
concussion. He gave her another shot of pain
medication and told me to let her sleep as long as possible. He added
that her ribs and leg would take many weeks to heal, but the pain would
gradually lesson.
While Dr. Sanders and I were talking, the phone rang. It was
Leon calling from Memphis to say he’d landed and would be home in two
hours. Although I longed to tell him everything that had happened, all I
said was, “I can’t wait to see you.”
After I hung up, Dr. Sanders said he
was surprised I hadn’t told Leon about Jo, showing remarkable restraint under
the circumstances. I answered that I wanted Leon to drive home carefully
with his mind on the road, not on recent events in Mound Bayou.
Shortly after Dr. Sanders left, I glanced out the front window and
saw Father Guidry and the 5 nuns coming up the road. I’d never before
seen them away from the church and their school and was surprised when they
turned into our driveway and walked up to our front door. I rushed to let
them in, grateful for the visit, knowing it would help pass the time until Leon
got home. Sister Rosarita asked if Jo was well enough for visitors and
said they’d like to see her. As the sisters walked toward Jo’s bedroom,
Father Guidry whispered that he wished to speak with me alone, so he and I
stayed behind on the porch to talk.
I listened in disbelief as Father Guidry said he thought that what
had happened to Jo was politically motivated. If the boys had really
wanted to rape Jo, they could easily have done so. He said this was a
message to our family to leave the area. We were trouble. We
disturbed the status quo. Father Guidry even went so far as to suggest
the boys may have been paid to rough Jo up.
He concluded, “You and your
family should leave Mound Bayou immediately, not only for Jo’s sake, but for
the sake of the town. If word gets out regarding this incident involving 4 black boys and a white girl, the Ku Klux Klan will have an excuse to burn
down the town.”
As much as I hated to believe that what he said was true, it made
sense. Why else did the boys show up at the clinic, apologizing for
having hurt Jo? Perhaps they’d never really intended to hurt her, but
were just trying to scare us, and things got out of hand. Perhaps they
didn’t know their own strength. In any case, Father Guidry told me the 2 boys who went to the parochial school would be expelled.
I hadn’t given any thought before to punishment for the
boys. I’d been so caught up in worrying about Jo that I hadn’t been
concerned about it. If something like this had happened back in Newton,
we would have called the police and brought criminal charges. But what could
we do in Mound Bayou? If what Father Guidry said was true, we couldn’t
risk going to the authorities. Many of the police were Ku Klux Klan
members and might respond with more violence. We’d moved to Mississippi
to help the black community, not to get it destroyed. Then it occurred to me
that my bringing Dr. King and Malcolm X into the high school caused all
this. Was I to blame? Trying to hide the turbulence inside me, I
walked quietly into Jo’s room, thanked the sisters for coming to the house, and
walked them and Father Guidry to the front door.
When I went to check in on Jo again, she was awake, talking softly
and laughing with Charles. She tried to sit up and found she could do so
without too much pain. Seeing this, and wanting everything to be as
normal as possible when Leon walked in the door, I asked if she thought she
could get out of bed and sit up somewhere. She said she’d like to try, so
with Charles on one side and me on the other, we moved toward the dining room
and helped her sit in one chair with her legs resting on another. The
three of us sitting at the table with the dog and cat at our feet were the
image of domestic tranquility.
Moments later, the front door open and Leon came bounding in as he
had so many times over the years, bringing love, joy, and fun into our
lives. He was in high spirits, excited by his trip and happy to be
home. He hugged me, picked up the dog, and playfully started to drop him
on top of Jo’s outstretched legs. We all yelled, “Don’t!”
Leon stopped just in time, with the dog barely an inch above Jo’s
bruised leg. He stared at us in bewilderment, put Pepper on the floor,
and then asked what was wrong. I spent the next hour telling him. Then he calmly picked up the phone to call Dr.
Sanders. They conversed physician to physician and by the end of their
conversation, Leon was sure the physical crisis was over. Only then did
his parental instincts take hold and he went to Philip’s bedroom, found a
baseball bat in the closet, and walked out the front door. He wandered
the neighborhood for an hour, looking for the boys who’d attacked Jo. He
told me later it was a good thing he didn’t find them, because he didn’t know
what he would have done had he been successful.
By the time he returned, he was ready to talk. I told him we
should leave Mound Bayou in the next couple of days. His initial reaction
was, “Absolutely not. We’ll stay through June, just as we planned.
This doesn’t change a thing.”
Perhaps he thought I needlessly feared we were in danger of
further attack. Or perhaps he was over whelmed by all that had happened and
wasn’t thinking clearly. In any case, he began to change his mind when I
said it was Father Guidry who said we should leave, that the incident was
politically motivated, and we would be placing the town in danger if we
stayed.
Before making a final decision, he spoke with Jo, asking her how
she felt about it. Jo said she wanted to leave, but didn’t
elaborate. Years later, she told me she was embarrassed about returning
to school, knowing all her friends would be aware that the boys had molested
her. Like many victims of rape or attempted rape, she felt as if she were
to blame, believing she’d somehow sent out a signal that this was okay and she
would welcome the boys’ advances. It seems obvious in retrospect that she
might think this way, and we should have provided her with an opportunity to
talk about it. Unfortunately, back in the sixties, rape counseling was
not yet commonplace.
We believed she was afraid to stay for fear she’d be beaten up
again, and that was enough for Leon to agree we should leave. He called
the University of Miami to see if he could start his new job in a couple of
weeks instead of at the beginning of July, and they answered, “The sooner, the
better.”
Having settled that, the next question was, “How soon can we
leave?” Jo was getting better by the hour and Leon assured me she was
well enough to travel. She still spent most of her time in bed and asleep
but was more comfortable than she’d been during the first 24 hours. As soon as we tied up a few loose ends at work and packed clothes
for the trip and the first few weeks in Miami, we could go. After talking
through what this would entail, we decided we could accomplish everything by
the following afternoon and begin our trip the morning after.
Over breakfast, we discussed the logistics for the day, beginning
with whether Charles should go to school. He wanted to stay home with Jo,
and we were concerned that if the incident two days earlier was truly
politically motivated, he might be in danger. For the same reason, we
decided not to leave the children at home alone while Leon and I went to
work. Instead, I would go to school briefly, pick up my belongings, and once I got home, Leon could go to the clinic.
When I walked into my classroom, the students were there with a
substitute teacher. As soon as they saw me, they started to ask
questions, but I held a finger to my lips and said they should continue
listening to the sub while I packed up my desk. They did as I asked, but
I could feel them watching me as I opened the top desk drawer and put my
personal belongings in a paper bag.
Next, I went to the 4 boxes of books sitting undisturbed on the
floor. As I stared at the books, I thought about how much trouble they’d
caused, wondering once again if the attack on Jo was a result of my attempts to
introduce black literature into the classroom. As I started to pick up one
of the boxes, a student called out, “Leave the books, Mrs. Kruger. We’re
going to read them.” Other students took up the cry, until they were all
begging me to let them keep the books. Encouraged by this sign that I had
made a difference for my students, I left the books, blew them a kiss, walked out of the building, and drove home.
As soon as I arrived, Leon took off for the clinic, promising to
be home in time for dinner. I looked in on Charles and found him in his
room packing his things. I walked aimlessly about the trailers for a few
minutes, finding it hard to believe we’d be leaving the following
morning. Then I sat with Jo, watching her sleep.
I was just about to start sorting through what to take with us to
Miami when the phone rang. It was Mr. Moore, the principal of the high
school, calling to ask me to address the students. They were roaming the
halls, refusing to sit in class. The rumor was flying through the school
that I’d been fired for bringing in the Martin Luther King and Malcolm X books.
Mr. Moore had tried to tell them my leaving had nothing to do with the books,
but they wouldn’t believe him. They wanted to hear it from me. I
said I’d be happy to come but didn’t feel safe leaving the children
alone. Since Leon would be at work for the rest of the day, I had to stay
home. He said he’d call back in a few minutes. When he did, he said
he’d arranged for a friend to stay with Charles and Jo, and I should come
straight to the gym as soon as she arrived.
When she did, I got into my car and drove one last time
to the school. As I looked into the gym, I saw that every student in the
school was sitting quietly in the stands with all the teachers lined up along
the walls. Mr. Moore was speaking into a microphone, telling the students
he’d sent for me and I would be arriving shortly. When I entered the room
and the students noticed me, they all began to applaud. Mr. Moore
signaled for me to sit in one of the chairs near the microphone while he
finished speaking. I did so, gesturing for silence, and the students
settled down.
Mr. Moore started talking again, and for the first time, he
used the term “Black” instead of “Negro.” I realized then I had made a
difference, not just with the students, but with adults as well.
When I got up to speak, I said, “You probably remember that I
started each of our speech classes by asking you to make impromptu
speeches. I didn’t know at the time that I would be making one on this,
my last day with you. But here I am. My daughter Jo was beaten up
over the weekend. She was sexually molested, though not raped. She
has two broken ribs, a concussion, and contusions on her leg that are so bad
she can’t walk. It will be many weeks before she is well again.”
I told them of the advice we’d received from Father Guidry, whom
they all knew and respected. I said he’d asked us to leave Mound Bayou as
quickly as possible for the safety of the town, that he was concerned the KKK
would hear that 4 black boys had attacked a white girl, and would retaliate.
I told my students how much I hated to leave them, that I treasured the time we
spent together in the classroom, but I wouldn’t endanger them by staying.
I concluded by saying how much I loved them and would miss
them. As I turned to leave, a number of them called out, “What about the
books?” I turned back and said what I thought would ease the tense
situation. “All adults want what’s best for you, parents and teachers
alike. We have many different ideas about education and do not always
agree about what’s the right thing to do. You know my beliefs. You
should read and broaden your horizons. You have the books. Read
them.”
I threw a kiss and turned to leave. Hundreds of students
came running out of the stands and surrounded me, blocking my way. Some
only wanted to hug me. Others wanted to say good-bye and promise me
they’d read the books. Others wept. It took a long time for me to
make my way to the door and as I walked out of the building, I thought of all my young charges and how much I would miss them.
Shortly after I arrived at home, Count Gibson and his wife showed
up at the door. They’d heard what happened to Jo and flew in from Boston
to offer support and sympathy. Perhaps Leon knew they were coming, but
their arrival took me by surprise.
Our next guest surprised me even more. Leon came home a
couple of hours later with one of the boys who had attacked Jo. The boy’s
mother accompanied them and Leon said they were anxious to talk to me and hoped
I would see them. The boy started to talk, rambling on about how sorry he
was, how they hadn’t meant to hurt Jo. I felt as if I’d heard it all
before and found it difficult to force myself to listen. Then he began
describing what had happened and I realized his description and my image of the
incident were very different. Not knowing yet why this discrepancy had
occurred, I interrupted him to ask how long they were up in the tree. He
said, “About 45 minutes.” Forty-five minutes? Forty-five
minutes!
I’d had no idea that Jo’s ordeal had lasted that long. I
started to sob, and the boy’s mother put a hand on my shoulder, trying to
comfort me, but I turned away. Leon ushered mother and son out and I
stumbled to the divan, buried my face in a cushion, and continued to cry.
I don’t know how long I sat there, but eventually I felt someone’s arms around
me. I turned and recognized Martha Tranquilli, a nurse who had been
working at the local hospital long before the Boston contingent arrived.
She stayed with me until I recovered and then brought me back to
the other trailer where Leon was preparing dinner.
Shortly after we finished eating, Jo fell asleep and Charles went
to his room to pack. Leon and I stood in the kitchen, cleaning up in silence,
unable to talk about my breakdown. Just as we put away the last of the
dishes, we heard a knock at the front door. About 20 of my students
stood outside, asking if they could come in to say goodbye. Leon invited
them into the living room where they settled on the chairs, the sofa, the piano
bench, and the floor. We talked for a while, reminiscing about favorite
times in the classroom and what they believed to be the most important life
lessons we’d discussed. While we talked, Leon went to the kitchen, began
emptying the refrigerator and cupboards, and returned with snacks for our
guests.
When they’d been there for half an hour, one of the students asked
if Jo was well enough to join us. He said he had something he wanted to
give her. I asked Leon to check on her and he returned a few minutes
later, half-carrying her from her bedroom. As she came into the living
room, she sank to the floor, exhausted from the effort. The students made
room for her, helped her to lie flat on her back so her ribs wouldn’t ache so
much, and placed a pillow under her head.
The student who’d asked for Jo knelt beside her and presented her
with a vase he had made in art class. He said, “I hope that every time
you look at this vase, you’ll think of all the people in Mound Bayou who care
about you and are sorry you were hurt. I don’t want your memories of your
two years here to focus on the events of the last few days, but on all the good
times you’ve had, on the friends you’ve made, and on how much we appreciate what
you and your family have done for us.” With that, he hugged Jo gently and
placed the vase next to her. It wasn’t long before she was sound asleep,
her hands clasped around the vase.
A few minutes later, one of the students pointed out that there
were other students waiting outside, milling about in our front yard. The
first group to visit left through the back door at the same time that another 20 came in through the front. Over the next few hours, several
hundred students streamed through, each staying for 10 to 15 minutes. One after another, the students said how sorry they were to see
us go, how much we were appreciated, and how they would never forget us.
The last of the students left just after midnight. It had been a
bittersweet evening, one we would remember vividly for the rest of our lives.
In the morning, Leon scrambled about the kitchen, making breakfast
from the little bit of food left over from the night before. We planned
to get an early start, driving in two cars as far as the airport in
Greenville. We’d leave Leon’s car there and continue the trip to Miami in
my car. Later, Leon would return to retrieve his car and sell the
trailers. Our departure was delayed, however, by the arrival of a new
group of visitors. In the same way that my students had come the night
before, Leon’s colleagues from the clinic came all morning. Many said
they’d tried to visit the previous evening, but when they drove by and saw
hundreds of students waiting their turn to come in, they decided to leave the
night to the teenagers and come instead in the morning.
It was almost noon before the last of Leon’s colleagues
left. Only then were we able to pack the cars and get Jo comfortably
settled in the back seat with the dog and cat. Charles sat beside her,
preferring to be near his sister rather than sitting up front with me.
Leon held the car door open as I slipped into the driver’s seat, squeezing my
hand one last time to assure me all would be well. Then Leon walked to
his car, started up the engine, and we were off. I pulled out onto the
road, finding it hard to believe that never again would I view Mound Bayou as
our home. Our new life was before us, and I had to be ready for it.
No comments:
Post a Comment